find the latest legal job
Supreme Court maintains silence amid crime sentencing controversy in Victoria

Supreme Court maintains silence amid crime sentencing controversy in Victoria

Supreme Court, scales of justice, crime, Victoria

The Supreme Court of Victoria has continued to hold its ground and impartiality, refusing to provide an official statement on a successful sentencing appeal that the High Court remitted back to the Victorian Court of Appeal.

The Supreme Court of Victoria has indicated that it will not issue any statement concerning claims published by NewsCorp this week involving recently retired Chief Justice Marilyn Warren AC.

On Thursday 12 October, an article in The Australian claimed that the former chief justice had exchanged a number of letters with the Victorian Director of Public Prosecutions John Champion SC.

The article suggested that during her tenure as Chief Justice, Marilyn Warren’s letters criticised the ODPP for its conduct in a sentencing appeal to the High Court of Australia (HCA). The judge was also alleged to have “demanded” the Crown ask the HCA to suspend a determination of the appeal until the issues between the office and the Victorian Supreme Court could be resolved.

A unanimous decision to allow the sentencing appeal of Victorian man Charlie Dalgliesh (a pseudonym), who was found guilty of incest, was made by the HCA this week. The bench found that the three-and-a-half year prison sentence the man had been given for sexually abusing the 13-year-old daughter of his de-facto partner was “manifestly inadequate” and allowed the appeal on the basis that there was “an error of principle”. One of the victims in the case became pregnant as a result of the abuse.

During the appeal hearing before the HCA in June this year, Victorian Chief Crown Prosecutor Gavin Silbert QC told the court that Victoria’s approach to current sentencing practices were “inimical” and “not permissible”.

The Australian article went on to suggest that one week later, while the appeal was under consideration, Chief Justice Warren wrote a letter to the DPP criticising its conduct. It was alleged that the judge “demanded” Mr Champion send further material to the High Court judges after closing arguments had been made.

The article also suggested Chief Justice Warren accused the DPP of misleading the court because it had not previously questioned the 2011 Victorian appeal decision of Ashdown, that would have a bearing on how criminal penalties in Victoria required consistency with “current sentencing practices”.

The letters from CJ Warren are also reported to include complaints that the DPP had long supported the sentencing practice of Victoria’s Court of Appeal.

“It is of course essential that the High Court not be misled. Unless what I have set out above misdescribes the positions you have previously taken, I would be grateful for your advice as to what steps you intend to take to correct the submissions advanced by the Chief Crown Prosecutor,” read an extract of one of the judge’s letters to the DPP.

The DPP contented that the doctrine of precedent made it difficult to ask the Victorian Court of Appeal to revisit its sentencing principles and so chose to challenge the sentence decision by appealing to the HCA.

Legal academic Professor Jeremy Gans from the Melbourne University posted his own take on the emerging controversy the Opinions on High blog run by Melbourne Law School.

Professor Gans explained in its reasons for allowing the appeal, the HCA said the determination of Dalgliesh’s sentence had been based on a current but wrong set of sentencing principles.

He went on to suggest that the timing of the leaked letters to coincide with the HCA’s decision this week was “surely partly designed to avoid a perception of influencing the High Court’s decision”.

“Yesterday, the High Court remitted the sentencing case to the Court of Appeal for fresh consideration of the DPP’s appeal. So, it is perhaps convenient that Warren CJ retired at the start of this month. Her successor, Anne Ferguson, was sworn in just as her predecessor’s letters were published,” Professor Gans said.

A spokesperson for the Victorian Supreme Court confirmed that it was not appropriate to comment in circumstances where a higher court had remitted the matter back to the Victorian Court of Appeal.

Promoted content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
more from lawyers weekly
Julian Assange
Oct 13 2017
When justice fails, according to Assange
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange has dismissed the capacity of judicial systems to deal with complex...
Aussie anti-terrorism laws, detention of 10-year-olds
Oct 13 2017
Treatment of kids under Aussie anti-terrorism laws an over-reach: ABA
The Australian Bar Association has urged the government to reconsider proposed reforms to Australian...
Supreme Court, scales of justice, crime, Victoria
Oct 13 2017
Supreme Court maintains silence amid crime sentencing controversy in Victoria
The Supreme Court of Victoria has continued to hold its ground and impartiality, refusing to provide...
Allens managing partner Richard Spurio, image courtesy Allens' website
Jun 21 2017
Promo season at Allens
A group of lawyers at Allens have received promotions across its PNG and Australian offices. ...
May 11 2017
Partner exits for in-house role
A Victorian lawyer has left the partnership of a national firm to start a new gig with state governm...
Esteban Gomez
May 11 2017
National firm recruits ‘major asset’
A national law firm has announced it has appointed a new corporate partner who brings over 15 years'...
Nicole Rich
May 16 2017
Access to justice for young transgender Australians
Reform is looming for the process that young transgender Australians and their families must current...
Geoff Roberson
May 11 2017
The lighter side of the law: when law and comedy collide
On the face of it, there doesn’t seem to be much that is amusing about the law, writes Geoff Rober...
May 10 2017
Advocate’s immunity – without fear or without favour but not both
On 29 March 2017, the High Court handed down its decision in David Kendirjian v Eugene Lepore & ...

Joomla! Debug Console


Profile Information

Memory Usage

Database Queries